Posted on September 29, 2025
As the Premier League's Monday night spotlight descends on Liverpool's Hill Dickinson Stadium, Everton host a beleaguered West Ham United in what promises to be a gritty encounter under the floodlights. Kick-off is at 21:00 CET (20:00 GMT), and with both sides nursing recent wounds, this clash could be the spark that ignites one team's season while extinguishing another's faint hopes. For Everton, it's a chance to build momentum after a mixed bag of results; for West Ham, it's do-or-die under new manager Nuno Espírito Santo, who steps into the fray just days after Graham Potter's dramatic sacking.
The Road to Goodison… or Hill Dickinson?
Everton kicked off the 2025/26 campaign with a stumble—a narrow opening-day loss—but quickly steadied the ship with back-to-back wins that hinted at the steel being forged under David Moyes. A hard-fought draw followed, keeping them in the hunt, but the Merseyside derby last weekend brought reality crashing down: a 2-1 defeat to rivals Liverpool at Anfield, where they battled valiantly but fell short. Midweek brought further frustration in the EFL Cup, a 2-0 loss to Wolverhampton Wanderers after heavy rotation left them exposed. Sitting 10th-12th in the table with seven points from five games, the Toffees are just three points off the European spots—a tantalizing gap that a win tonight could halve.
Contrast that with West Ham's nightmare start. Four losses from five, including three where they shipped three or more goals, have left them rooted to 19th with a miserly three points and the league's worst defensive record (13 conceded). Potter's tenure, which began with optimism after his January arrival, unraveled amid boardroom pressure and on-pitch chaos, culminating in his dismissal on Saturday alongside much of his staff. Nuno, fresh off his Nottingham Forest exit, inherits a squad that spent £126 million in the summer on reinforcements like Mateus Fernandes and Soungoutou Magassa, yet looks disjointed and vulnerable. The "new manager bounce" is a real phenomenon, but against an Everton side hungry for home points, it might feel more like a rude awakening.
Head-to-Head: A History of Toffee Toughness
These two have locked horns 51 times in league play, with Everton holding a commanding edge: 25 wins to West Ham's 12, and 14 draws. The Toffees have netted 92 goals to the Hammers' 55 in Premier League meetings alone, showcasing their historical dominance on Merseyside. Their last encounter in March 2025 ended in a tense 1-1 draw, with Jake O’Brien’s stoppage-time header salvaging a point after Tomáš Souček’s opener. Recent form tilts further Everton's way: they've won three of the last five head-to-heads, while West Ham have managed just one victory in that span.
| Key H2H Stats | Everton | West Ham | Draws |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Wins (All Comps) | 25 | 12 | 14 |
| Premier League Goals | 92 | 55 | - |
| Last 5 Meetings | 3 Wins, 1 Draw, 1 Loss | 1 Win, 1 Draw, 3 Losses | - |
Team News: Injuries and Intrigue
Everton head into the game without key defenders Jarrad Branthwaite (thigh) and Merlin Röhl (groin), both sidelined and not yet match-fit. That thrusts more responsibility on James Tarkowski and Michael Keane at the back, with Vitaliy Mykolenko anchoring the left. Up top, Beto leads the line, supported by a creative trio of Iliman Ndiaye, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, and the talismanic Jack Grealish, whose summer move from Manchester City has already paid dividends with his flair and work rate. Predicted lineup (4-2-3-1): Pickford; O'Brien, Tarkowski, Keane, Mykolenko; Gueye, Garner; Ndiaye, Dewsbury-Hall, Grealish; Beto.
West Ham's absentee list is equally grim: Tomáš Souček serves the second game of his suspension, while Aaron Wan-Bissaka sits out with a stomach bug. Nuno's first selection could see Kyle Walker-Peters at right-back, with Max Kilman and Konstantinos Mavropanos in central defense. Expect a pragmatic setup, perhaps 4-2-3-1, leaning on Jarrod Bowen and Crysencio Summerville for width, Lucas Paquetá pulling strings in midfield, and Niclas Füllkrug as the focal point. Predicted: Areola; Walker-Peters, Mavropanos, Kilman, Diouf; Magassa, Fernandes; Bowen, Paquetá, Summerville; Füllkrug.
Key Battles: Where the Game Will Be Won or Lost
- Grealish vs. West Ham's Backline: The Englishman has been a revelation since joining Everton, terrorizing full-backs with his dribbles and deliveries. If he exploits Walker-Peters' inexperience in the role, expect fireworks—and perhaps a goal or assist.
- Midfield Scrap: Gueye/Garner vs. Paquetá/Fernandes: Everton's engine room has been combative, but West Ham's flair players could unlock them if Nuno instills early confidence.
- Set-Pieces: The Decider? Both teams have leaky defenses from dead balls—West Ham conceded from corners in recent games, while Everton's aerial threats (O’Brien, Tarkowski) loom large.
Prediction: Everton to Edge a Tense Affair
This feels like a classic low-scoring Premier League grind, with Everton's home solidity (averaging 1.2 goals scored and just 1.10 xGA at Hill Dickinson) clashing against West Ham's desperation. The Hammers' away form is dire (one win all season), and despite the managerial fresh start, I see the Toffees grinding out a 2-1 victory—Grealish with a moment of magic, Beto nodding home the winner. Both teams to score? Likely, given West Ham's porous backline and Everton's recent openness. Under 2.5 total goals at 4/5 odds looks tempting for the cautious punter.
As the whistle blows, Everton fans will chant for three points to banish derby demons, while West Ham supporters cling to Nuno's honeymoon period. One thing's certain: in the cauldron of Monday night football, anything can happen. COYB! ⚪🔵
Follow me on X for live updates and post-match reaction. What's your score prediction? Drop it in the comments below.